Assets measured in generations
A master instrument is not considered in quarters. It is considered in successions of ownership — and you are one of them.
An asset that is not counted in years
Master instruments are among the few assets whose time horizon regularly exceeds the lifespan of their owners — not as an exception, but as the rule.
An instrument from a significant eighteenth-century Italian workshop has typically had between twelve and twenty owners: collectors, musicians, families, institutions. Holding periods have generally run to one or two decades.
This produces an unusual frame of reference. What matters is not your own holding period but the chain of transitions. Whoever acquires such an instrument enters an existing line and helps prepare the next handover.
The difference from every other tangible asset
With almost every tangible asset, use stands in opposition to preservation. A car that is driven loses value. A watch that is worn loses value. A sheet of paper frequently exhibited loses value.
With stringed instruments, that relationship is reversed.
The wood, varnish and glue joints of an instrument that is played are under constant vibration. If that vibration is absent for a long period, the instrument’s response changes — its voice closes. Since tonal quality is an essential part of what the instrument is, use here is not consumption of substance. It is care of substance.
The proper place for a master instrument is therefore not a vault. It is the hands of a musician who works with it every day.
Beyond the two familiar dividends
At VIOLIN ASSETS we speak of two dividends: the development of the asset over time, and the experience of hearing your own instrument played in a concert hall by a musician on the way up.
For owners who think in generations, a third is added: the handover.
A master instrument passes to the next generation differently from a statement of account. It has a name, a workshop, a year of making, a line of previous owners and a recording history. Whoever inherits it inherits not an entry in a schedule but an object with a biography — and with an obligation attached to it.
That changes how families talk about it. A portfolio is discussed once, at the notary. An instrument continues to be discussed.
What we do about it
Holding an instrument as a generational asset requires that the transition be prepared.
-
Documentation and provenance
Evidenced records of origin, attribution, restoration work and playing history. An instrument without adequate papers is considerably harder to handle at the point of transfer.
-
Preservation of condition
Regular inspection, referral to appropriate master workshops, supervision of loans. Condition determines what the next generation is able to do.
-
Succession planning
Coordination with your legal and tax advisers on how the instrument should be treated in the estate — as an individual item, within a structure, or subject to conditions on continued use.
-
Avoiding a forced break-up
The most common loss with master instruments in private hands is not a fall in value. It is a community of heirs unable to agree, selling without knowledge of the market. Avoiding that requires arrangements made in advance.
In confidence, without haste
Matters of this kind are not decided in a single meeting. We accompany those responsible over extended periods and in coordination with your existing advisers.
Christian Reister
VIOLIN ASSETS GmbH
Opernplatz 14, 60313 Frankfurt am Main